What is the Appeal Tribunal?
The Appeal Tribunal is a group of up to five (5) individuals appointed by Council who have been granted the authority to make decisions regarding appeals related to infractions or Administrative Monetary Penalties under the following bylaws:
Requesting an Appeal
A request for an appeal, as outlined in Bylaw 2020.66 Appeal Tribunal Bylaw, must be submitted to the Township in person or by mail within 15 days after receipt of a penalty notice. The date on the notice is considered to be day one (1). If mailing in the request, please ensure it is received within the 15 day time frame.
Once an application for an appeal has been received by the Township, along with the applicable filing fee, the Tribunal Coordinator will send the Appellant and the Tribunal a 'Notice of Hearing' which will contain the date, time and location of the hearing. Hearings take place on an as needed basis.
Request for Appeal
Request for Extension of Time
Preparing for an Appeal
The Appeal Tribunal hearing format is similar to the format of a court hearing. The following people may be in attendance:
- One (1) Tribunal Coordinator
- One (1) Tribunal Chair
- Up to four (4) Tribunal Members
- One (1) Township of Ramara Case Presenter
- One (1) Township of Ramara Witness (typically the Bylaw Enforcement Officer who laid the penalty or dealt with the file)
- The Appellant(s)
- Members of the Public
During the hearing, all parties will sit in the Council Chambers or another meeting room at the Township of Ramara Administration Building.
Access to upcoming meeting agendas can be found on our CivicWeb (Agendas and Minutes) page.
Meeting Agenda
What to bring to an Appeal
To protect your privacy and to ensure a fair hearing, Tribunal Members are only given the Appeal File number and topic beforehand (e.g. an appeal regarding an Administrative Monetary Penalty relating to the Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11). The complete Appeal Hearing application will be circulated to members of the Tribunal at the start of the hearing.
If you wish to submit additional information into evidence, please bring enough copies for all Tribunal members (6 copies total, for 5 members, plus the Coordinator). Note that documents will not be returned to you once entered into evidence. Documents must be legible, and any photos must be clear.
Appeal Hearing Format
- Appeal Tribunal Coordinator will swear in Township and Appellant’s witnesses
- Township's Case Presenter will give their opening address and provide copies of their evidence (if applicable)
- The Appellant will give their opening address and provide copies of their evidence (if applicable)
- The Township's Case Presenter will provide closing remarks
- The Appellant will provide closing remarks
- The Township Case Presenter and the Appellant will then be asked to leave the meeting so the Tribunal can discuss options and make their decision. Both parties will be advised in writing of the Tribunal's decision.
Appeal Tribunal Decisions
2025 Decisions
|
2025 Appeal Tribunal Decisions
Hearing Date | File # | Address | Appeal Type | Tribunal Decision |
February 20 |
2025.01 |
38 Creighton Street |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Fine lowered to $50.00 |
February 20 |
2025.02 |
2765 Maple Ave |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
February 20 |
2025.03 |
4252 Plum Point Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
February 20 |
2025.04 |
4081 Bonnie Beach Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
February 20 |
2025.05 |
6414 Line 2 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP
|
February 20 |
2025.06 |
6018 Mariposa Beach Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP
|
|
2024 Decisions
|
2024 Appeal Tribunal Decisions
Hearing Date | File # | Address | Appeal Type | Tribunal Decision |
February 1 |
2024.02 |
79 Simcoe Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Hearing Deferred |
February 1 |
2024.03 |
41 Old Indian Trail |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
February 1 |
2024.04 |
8072 Oakridge Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
April 30 |
2024.01 |
3790 Muley Point Lane |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
April 30 |
2024.02 |
79 Simcoe Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $1000 AMP
No Demerit Points Assessed
|
April 30 |
2024.05 |
19 Rosy Beach Court |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP
|
April 30 |
2024.06 |
4906 Highway 12 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2000 AMP
|
August 29 |
2024.07 |
5225 Prospect Ave |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
UP HOLD $3000.00 AMP
|
August 29 |
2024.08 |
1209 Ramara Road 47 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
UP HOLD $3000.00 AMP
|
August 29 |
2024.12 |
31 Paradise Blvd |
Time Extension |
Denied
|
October 16 |
2024.09 |
1152 Concession Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
UP HOLD $3000.00 AMP
|
October 16 |
2024.10 |
4298 Plum Point Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Deferred
|
October 16 |
2024.14 |
4298 Plum Point Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Withdrawn
|
December 17 |
2024.11 |
4781 Byers Lane |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
UP HOLD $3000.00 AMP
|
December 17 |
2024.13 |
4781 Byers Lane |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
UP HOLD $3000.00 AMP
|
December 17 |
2024.14 |
4298 Plum Point Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Withdrawn
|
December 17 |
2024.10 |
4298 Plum Point Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Withdrawn
|
December 17 |
2024.15 |
8144 Laid Law Ave |
Time Extension |
Denied
|
|
2023 Decisions
|
2023 Appeal Tribunal Decisions
Hearing Date | File # | Address | Appeal Type | Tribunal Decision |
February 10 |
2022.08 |
47 Lake Avenue |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
February 10 |
2022.09 |
8168 Laidlaw Avenue |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduced $2000 AMP |
February 10 |
2022.10 |
7260 Glen Ellen Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
February 10 |
2022.11 |
7260 Glen Ellen Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
August 2 |
2023.01 |
7884 Pineridge Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
August 2 |
2023.02 |
1299 Furniss Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
August 2 |
2023.03 |
1299 Furniss Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $2500 AMP |
August 2 |
2023.04 |
1299 Furniss Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
September 13 |
2023.05 |
4109 Bonnie Beach Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
September 13 |
2023.06 |
7806 Riverleigh Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
September 13 |
2023.07 |
4109 Bonnie Beach Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $1500 AMP |
September 13 |
2023.08 |
4906 Highway 12 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
AMP Dismissed |
September 13 |
2023.09 |
4787 Byers Lane |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
AMP Dismissed |
September 13 |
2023.10 |
7806 Riverleigh Drive |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Uphold $3000 AMP |
November 2 |
2023.11 |
1342 Black Beach Lane |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduced $2500 AMP |
November 2 |
2023.12 |
4906 Highway 12 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
November 2 |
2023.13 |
4906 Highway 12 |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Extension Denied |
|
2022 Decisions
|
2022 Appeal Tribunal Decisions
Hearing Date | File # | Address | Appeal Type | Tribunal's Decision |
August 9 |
2022.01 |
2197 Concession Road 4 |
Long Grass Bylaw 2014.36 AMP |
Uphold AMP |
August 31 |
2022.02 |
2197 Concession Road 4 |
Long Grass Bylaw 2014.36 AMP |
Reduce $250 AMP |
September 26 |
2022.03 |
5 Rosy Beach Court |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduce $200 AMP |
September 26 |
2022.04 |
17 Rosy Beach Court |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduce $200 AMP |
October 20 |
2022.05 |
13 Rosy Beach Court |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduce $1000 AMP |
October 20 |
2022.06 |
4109 Bonnie Beach Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduce $800 AMP |
November 14 |
2022.07 |
79 Simcoe Road |
Short Term Rental Accommodation Bylaw 2020.11 AMP |
Reduce $500 AMP
|
|